BlueskyLinkedInRedditFacebookEmailCopy link

Simon Evans

Published

🧵A political/media guide to the "truth" about net-zero

1) Add up costs to install & run a net-zero energy system 2) Pretend fossil-fuelled alternatives wld be free 3) Do say "eco zealots are bankrupting us" 4) Don't say "free cars if we scrap net-zero" cos it sounds ridiculous 5) That's it!

1/10

I realise this probably sounds like I'm making things up or being flippant

The Times covered this "£4.5tn cost of net-zero" story too, surely there's more to it…?

But honestly, please read on and I'll walk you through it 2/10

Let's look at the source of the Mail's "£4.5 trillion"

Table EA.06 (pic) from the National Energy System Operator (NESO) shows the cost of installing & running a net-zero UK energy system 2025-2050

If we take CAPEX only (My A + B in the table) we get = £4.5tn

I'll explain "CAPEX" in a sec 3/10

For bonus points, if you want to make this sound even scarier, why not try…

CAPEX + OPEX (My A+B+C+D) = £7.6tn

Apparently this was too tempting and will be making an appearance later today 4/10

To be clear, this is the total cost to install and run the UK energy system

CAPEX = buying energy-related equipment (an electric car, a windfarm, a heat pump for your home) OPEX = paying to keep it running (electricity, staff, servicing etc)

(see NESO table EA.A.03) 5/10

You could call this the "cost of net-zero" – as long as you think the fossil alternatives are free

(CAPEX) Free petrol cars! (CAPEX) Free gas-fired power stations! (OPEX) Free petrol! (OPEX) Free electricity from coal and gas!

Wouldn't that be nice 6/10

But petrol cars do cost money – and there's been massive cost inflation for gas turbines

NESO looked at the cost of "carrying on with fossil fuels" too, in a scenario called "Falling Behind" – and it was only £0.36tn cheaper in cash terms than “Holistic Transition”

7/10

So now we have gone from "staggering £4.5 / £7.6 TRILLION cost of net-zero"…

…to something that is 10-20x cheaper 8/10

But there's more

As I wrote at the time, NESO said net-zero "Holistic Transition" was the "cheapest option", once you take account of the economic damages from CO2 adding to climate change

It said a fossil energy system is only “cheaper” if we “ignore” carbon costs

carbonbrief.org/... 9/10

If you want to check out the NESO data tables for yourself, here’s the link:

It’s this link: neso.energy/... On this page: neso.energy/...

/ENDS 10/10