Sign in to bookmarkSign In
BlueskyLinkedInRedditFacebookEmailCopy link

Jonathan Portes

Published · Updated

In addition to this absurd chart, the article is full of Daily Mail/CSJ tropes (confusing "benefits" with all state spending, talking about "work incentives" while ignoring fact PIP is non-means tested, etc, etc). Inexcusable from FT.

Britain's welfare ratchet. My column for @financialtimes.com. Political incentives, rising expectations on the state & deeper economic failings make the UK's benefits system hard to rein in. as.ft.com/...

Since @tejparikh.ft.com has (perfectly reasonably) asked for me to be specific in my criticisms, here they are. I could go on but I think this will suffice.

1. As pretty much everyone else has told you, it is just absolutely inexcusable to use a real terms chart as your *headline* to illustrate welfare spending over multiple decades (just as it would be if it were tax revenue, debt, or NHS spending). This should not need explaining to an FT journalist.

Appending @tejparikh.ft.com's (utterly unconvincing - frankly I don't think he's even convinced himself) response here, and you can also see my reply

1.The chart serves as a high-level illustration to structure the points in my piece. 1st the largest slice of the bill, pensions, then the current focus on Pips...It is an accurate chart & feel it is fair for me to use it this way. Ofc any charts can be misused, hence I make the % of GDP point above

Point 2. It's correct that the footnote is clear. But I would amazed if the majority of readers even of the FT understood the point. The chart title, in an article about welfare benefits, is highly misleading.

2. That chart is from ONS "Table 16: ...individuals in households receiving more in benefits than they pay in taxes" I make clear that it is both benefits & benefits in kind in the footnote. Even so, the chart is indicative of my point around political constituencies for state support.

Point 3. In which it's hard to conclude that @tejparikh.ft.com isn't simply recycling CSJ slop without understanding either how the system works or how it has evolved.

Maybe I've not fully understood your point. But I guess my point is that it is perfectly rational to assume that higher benefits relative to the minimum wage raises the reservation wage. (as I say in "parts of the welfare system" ...there can be little or no incentive for someone to enter work..)

At some point @tejparikh.ft.com should stop digging. The argument that "I did it this way because I had the DWP £ real spend data series and I couldn't be bothered to go to the ONS site to download the £ real GDP one" is not very convincing...

No conspiracy. Dwp has the full historic data in real terms and i wanted a chart to make clear how big pensions were and to highlight recent pip growth (if anything it shows how small it is)

This appears to be @tejparikh.ft.com's defence -he doesn't have to explain/justify his choice of charts to me. Fine. He doesn't. We are entitled to draw our own conclusions about his credibility here.

I dont need to justify myself to you Jonathan. And your binary doesnt capture it anyway. I know why I did what I did. You can continue accusing me of being disingenuous if you get a kick out of it.