Sign in to bookmarkSign In
BlueskyLinkedInRedditFacebookEmailCopy link

John Bull

Published

The US granted visas to Jews but only allowed 30,000 in from Germany a year. You had to wait for your number to come up.

Meet Robert Smallbones. An unassuming British diplomat who 'hacked' this system so effectively (saving 48 THOUSAND Jews) the UK government kept his scheme secret for decades /1 🧵

old couple (Robert and his wife Inga), dressed in smart clothes. both look unassuming and like they could be anybodies' grandparents.
Another element is that even Jews who scraped together the cash and documents to flee were often refused entry by ‘safe’ nations, including the USA and U.K. A lot of Americans are not eligible for foreign long term visas.

Smallbones was exactly the kind of chap he looks like in this photo (with his wife Inga). Small 'c' conservative. Described as a bit dull but always good company. Happy family man.

A solid diplomat. In 1932, the Foreign Office sent him to Munich. By '38 he's British Consul-General in Frankfurt /2

an older gent with a moustache in a suit, next to his wife in a string of pearls. they look very british.

Smallbones was horrified. In Germany he witnessed increasing state violence against Jews. He wrote constant warnings to the Foreign Office.

The Nazis officially complained, after Smallbones daughter horse-whipped a Gestapo officer to try and stop the abduction of a Jewish man on the street. /3

9th November, 1938. Kristallnacht. The Nazi Party's brutal pogrom against German Jews.

As the horror and murder rages through Frankfurt, desperate Jews begin arriving at the British Consulate pleading for help.

Smallbones is in London when it happens, but Inga and his family take the initiative /4

Inga Smallbones orders the gates of the British Consulate opened. Through Kristallnacht, to the fury and protest of the German authorities, the Frankfurt Consulate becomes a small, untouchable refuge for the Jewish community of Frankfurt.

When Smallbones finds out the next day, he decides to act /5

Calling in favours, Smallbones organises a meeting between senior people in the Home and Foreign Offices. Insists a refugee scheme needs creating.

He's told that everyone agrees what's happening to the Jews is awful, but a refugee scheme would be politically unpalatable. So nothing can be done. /6

Unwilling to accept defeat, Smallbones hunts for a solution.

He realises the USA is sneakier about how it blocks Jews from immigrating. It gives them visas, but then only lets a certain percentage a year use them.

He thinks about how to 'hack' this, and comes up with a British-based workaround. /7

Smallbones proposes that the Home Office allow Jews who have a valid US visa to "wait" in Britain until their turn in the US arrivals queue comes up. Essentially, a TEMPORARY visa for Britain, that expires when they get to America.

The Home Secretary, Viscount Hoare agrees in principle. /8

Smallbones calls Otto Schiff of the Jewish Relief Agency. Over lunch at the Savoy they frantically draft up the scheme properly. Hoare's order is to do it in a way that means he doesn't need to go to Parliament with it.

Hoare and the Home Office sign it off that night: The Smallbones Scheme. /9

The next day, a message is flashed to all British Consulates in Germany:

You can grant temporary visas to those on the US waiting list. BUT:

1) EVERY exemption needs to be signed PERSONALLY by the relevant Consul. 2) We're not ordering you to. Just highlighting it's okay, if you're asked. /10

The caveats were inserted to avoid it spooking parliament or the German authorities. The idea was to create a system that wasn't possible to do at scale.

But that underestimated the drive of people like Robert Smallbones in Frankfurt, or Frank Foley in Berlin. /11

Smallbones returned to Frankfurt and kicked things into action. He immediately informed local Jewish Community leaders of the scheme's existence.

Importantly, he told them that he would allow FAMILIES to apply on behalf of anyone already seized by the Gestapo and imprisoned or sent to camps. /12

Smallbones then informed the Gestapo that if he approved a visa, that immediately placed that Jewish person under the protection of the British and he expected them to be IMMEDIATELY released when he asked.

It was a lie, and a gamble. But it worked. The Gestapo fumed about it, but complied. /13

Smallbones then turned the entire Frankfurt British Consulate into a machine with one job: getting Jews out of Germany to safety in Britain. But the bottleneck remained:

The Consul (Smallbones himself) had to sign EVERYTHING, and often the Gestapo would only release people if he went personally /14

For 9 months he worked 18hr days signing visas and arguing with the Gestapo.

"After two hours sleep my conscience pricked me. The feeling was horrible that there were people in concentration camp whom I could get out and that I was comfortable in bed. I returned to my desk and stayed there" /15

One survivor:

"My husband was in the concentration camp. And while I tried to get him out it was too terrible for one to even cry. Then at last I went to the British Consul to see if he could help me. And the first thing they asked me was: 'have you had anything to eat today?'" /16

"I hadn't of course. I was too worried to think of food. And before they did anything else, they fed me with coffee and sandwiches, as though I had been a guest. And then, I cried."

Smallbones, assisted by Inga, his daughter and the Consulate staff, worked endlessly to save lives. /19

At war's start, Smallbones was evacuated back to Britain along with all other diplomatic staff and their families. By this point he had made the Nazi list of people to be rounded up, if Britain was invaded.

He enquired how many people had gotten visas through his scheme.

48,000 Jews. /20

Smallbones was privately thanked for his efforts, then asked to keep the success of his Jewish evacuation visa scheme quiet. It was felt it may cause issues with both the British public and the US government.

In December 1939, he became Consul General in Brazil, where he retired in 1945. /21

Smallbones died in 1976. He seems never to have talked about what he did. I suspect like others he felt guilt at not saving more.

The British Government acknowledged the existence of the Smallbones Scheme in 2008.

He was posthumously awarded the medal of a British Hero of the Holocaust in 2013 /22

I like to highlight Robert Smallbones to people because he was an administrator and diplomat who, faced with the horrors of antisemitism and abduction in Germany, did what he could.

He wasn't perfect. His views on homosexuality were not great, even for the time.

But he saw wrong, and he acted /END