Sign in to bookmarkSign In
BlueskyLinkedInRedditFacebookEmailCopy link

Dan Neidle

Published

Our new report: Richard Tice signed accounts wrongly claiming £98,000 of tax exemptions

A 🧵 with the evidence:

What should have happened: the REIT paid no tax but the Tice companies holding shares in the REIT paid £98k tax on the dividends they received.

What actually happened: none of the companies paid any tax.

Normal companies pay corporation tax. So, when they pay dividends, their corporate shareholders don't pay tax again. The dividends are exempt.

REITs are different. They don't pay corporation tax. So dividends received by Tisun One, Two, Three, Four were not exempt.

Quidnet Reit structure chart showing its corporate shareholders:

Tisun One Ltd
Tisun Two Ltd
Tisun Three Ltd
Tisun Four Ltd

Richard Tice applied for his Quidnet company to become a REIT. It then paid no tax.

But the price was that the four "Tisun" companies holding shares in Quidnet REIT had to pay tax on their dividends. They didn't.

(here's the accounts from one of them)

The Tisun Three 2021 tax reconciliation showing the dividend exemption eliminating tax.

It was a really basic tax mistake. Everyone in REIT world knows that REIT corporate shareholders pay tax on their dividends - this isn't some deep tax nerd point.

I'd expect Richard Tice to know it. I'd certainly expect his advisers to know it. It's a google search away.

Richard Tice had a different explanation for why no tax was paid when he spoke to the Sunday Times last month.

Tice's statements here are all incorrect.

Sunday Times headline from March: Reform's Richard Tice avoided nearly £600k in tax
Despite receiving dividends, the companies paid zero tax in 2019, 2020 and 2021 for reasons that Tice said related to wider losses suffered by the groups. Although no such information appears in their accounts, he said: “The accountants advise on this and sign the audit and they are top drawer so I trust them.”

1. The companies weren't audited.

2. The accounts show the dividend exemption was claimed - wrongly. They don't show group losses being used.

3. And there were no losses in the group.

First, the easy one: the accounts weren't audited. It says so on the front page.

The front page of Tisun Three's accounts. It says they're "unaudited".

Second, the accounts don't show what Tice claimed.

This (T3, 2021) shows £60,906 of dividend income and says expected tax = £11,572, but cancelled by dividend exemption.

Not losses.

And **There is no dividend exemption for REIT distributions**

Tax reconciliation showing £11,572 of tax being cancelled by £11,572 of dividend exemption.

Maybe someone was being sloppy and typed "dividend income" when they really meant "dividend income is sheltered by losses".

Nope. The code the accountants' software submitted to Companies House contains a specific dividend exemption tag

More in this in our report.

iXBRL code showing the tag TaxIncreaseDecreaseFromEffectDividendsFromCompanies was applied to the negative 11,572 figure

The wrong use of the dividend exemption appears over all four companies for three years.

The total untaxed income was £513,901. The corporation tax rate at the time was 19%, and so the unpaid tax was £97,641.

Full workings/reconciliations in our report.

A table showing total REIT distributions received by the Tisun companies over three years were:

Tisun One: £161,202
Tisun Two: £160,876
Tisun Three: £160,876
Tisun Four: £30,947

Total: £513,901

The accounts weren't audited. We don't know who prepared them, but Richard Tice signed them:

Richard Tice signed Tisun accounts for 2021

But maybe Tice is right now and the accounts were wrong in 2022? Maybe the Tisun companies were using group losses?

Problem is: there were no group losses.

Here's the group.

The only companies that could have had losses for the Tisun companies to use were Tisun Holdco and Tisun Investments.

A group structure chart showing the four Tisun companies held by Tisun Investments.

Tisun Investments held by Tisun Holdco

Tisun Holdco held by Richard Tice.

Tisun Holdco was a nothingburger. Can't have made losses.

Tisun Holdco's 2021 balance sheet showing only £32k of assets and no change in the profit and loss account from the previous year.

Tisun Investments much busier.

So maybe Tisun Investment had big tax losses it surrendered to the Tisun companies?

Tisun Investments' balance sheet - £3.1m of assets and about a £70k fall in profit and loss account over the year.

Nope. Because these were its assets:

- £600k of unmortgaged residential real estate - a car on HP - £120k of unlisted investments - shareholdings in its subs - Loans to related parties - a loan to Reform UK

None could generate material tax losses

And its liabilities:

- 270,000 preference shares at 7% (ignored for tax) - interest-free loans from related parties

None could generate material tax losses

(Way more detail on all this in our report; what the assets/liabilities were and why no tax losses could arise)

So Tisun Investments Ltd did not generate material losses that could be used to shelter profits elsewhere in the group.

(It looks like its accountants agreed, as there’s no sign of a deferred tax asset, or any mention of losses or group relief.)

TL;DR

The Tisun companies failed to pay tax on £514k of dividends.

Richard Tice's claim this was because of losses is contradicted by

- the accounts, which show a (wrong) use of dividend exemption - the fact there **were no material losses**

So: £98k of corporation tax is due. Plus about £27k of interest

This was a really basic mistake. Everyone in REIT world knows that REIT distributions are taxed - it's not some point only the tax nerds know

That means HMRC are likely to assess penalties for carelessness

We asked Richard Tice's lawyer for comment.

We didn't receive a response (and neither did the Sunday Times).

Dear Mr Lewis,

I am writing to request Mr Tice's comments on another report we will be publishing in conjunction with The Sunday Times, concerning the tax structuring of Quidnet REIT.

As the Sunday Times reported in March, four companies - Tisun One Ltd, Tisun Two Ltd, Tisun Three Ltd and Tisun Four Ltd - received over £500,000 in dividends from Quidnet but paid no corporation tax. 

Mr Tice told the Sunday Times that this was due to losses elsewhere in the group, and "the accountants advise on this and sign the audit and they are top drawer so I trust them"

In reality:

1. None of the Tisun companies had an auditor. The only person signing the accounts was Mr Tice.

2. the accounts of Tisun One/Two/Three/Four don't show losses being used. They show the dividends as tax exempt. This was a basic tax error: dividends/PIDs from REITs are fully taxable.
3. there were no material tax losses in the group. Our team has reviewed the filed accounts of the wider Tisun group. They show neither sufficient qualifying tax losses nor any business activity capable of generating losses of the scale required to shelter the Tisun companies' REIT income.

We will be reporting that the explanation Mr Tice provided was incorrect, and that the company unlawfully failed to pay c£100k of tax. 

We will say that we expect HMRC will be able to recover that tax, plus about £27,000 of interest. Because this is such a simple point, we expect HMRC to regard the error as "careless" and seek penalties of 10-15%.

If you have any comments, please provide them by 5pm tomorrow.

Yours sincerely,

Dan Neidle

Full details in our report, including how we come up with the numbers, and why we are so confident there were no losses in the group. 25 tax lawyers and accountants contributed - for which many thanks.

https://buff.ly/9v30CL2

We worked on this story with Gabriel Pogrund of The Sunday Times - his story is here: buff.ly/...

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/politics/article/richard-tice-corporation-tax-reform-ttq9cp60f

Disclosure: I'm a member of the Labour Party. But everyone paying attention knows I call it as I see it.

I've investigated Rayner, Starmer, Lavery, Zahawi.

I've refuted accusations that Jeremy Hunt (twice), Rishi Sunak and Nigel Farage avoided tax.

I annoy everyone.

If you want to read more communist Labour neoliberal Tory toff analysis, you can follow me here or subscribe at taxpolicy.org.uk/...