1/ Elon Musk's interference with Starlink appears to have pushed Ukraine to adopt an Israeli satellite communication system to increase the effectiveness of its strikes on Russian oil refineries. This may enable last-minute changes to Ukrainian drones' targets. ⬇️
2/ Multiple Russian oil refineries have suffered extremely damaging drone strikes in the past two weeks. Unlike previously, where specific pieces of machinery in the refineries were targeted, the latest strikes have involved large numbers of drones hitting the entire complex.
3/ Debris reportedly recovered from a crashed Ukrainian drone indicate that it was being controlled using compact SmartLight Sirius 16x16 / ORION Ku satellite terminals from the Israeli defence technology company hiSky.
4/ The system uses French and British satellite constellations, rather than the American Starlink. France's Eutelsat provides 100% coverage of the entire territory of Russia, albeit with a high latency of 600-800 ms, which makes it unusable for manual piloting.
5/ Lower-orbiting British OneWeb satellites provide better latency in Russia's western border regions of Kursk, Belgorod, and Bryansk, plus Crimea and over the Black Sea, enabling Ukraine to use it for direct control of unmanned surface vessels and attack drones in those areas.
6/ While hiSky is technically inferior to Starlink, with speeds of 7 to 2000 kbps compared to Starlink's tens or hundreds of megabits per second, this is said to be sufficient for use as a "digital leash" – for sending short telemetry packets and receiving commands.
7/ This enables the Ukrainians to transmit navigation packets and adjust flight missions for UAVs flying deep behind Russian lines. Russian warblogger Boris Rozhin notes:
8/ "HiSky's kilobit capacity is more than sufficient for this, and the low data transfer rate, combined with the narrow beam of the phased array, makes these terminals resistant to detection by ELINT air defence systems and invulnerable to ground-based electronic warfare.
9/ "Furthermore, the Israeli terminals are a purely military design from the outset, meeting all the corresponding reliability and security requirements."
10/ 'Artjockey' suggests that the adoption of hiSky is enabling Ukraine to hit Russian oil refineries harder and with greater precision:
11/ "It is no longer a secret that the key is the HiSKY terminals. They do not allow operators to control drones, but they do allow for telemetry and on-the-fly changes to routes and attack targets.
12/ "This seemingly small change allows for a much larger number of targets to be hit at a single facility at once. Moreover, it seems that Ukraine itself was not expecting such an increase in efficiency.
13/ "As far as I know, these terminals have been available to Kyiv for some time, but it seems that no one has tried to use them en masse on long-range drones.
14/ "I suspect that Ukrainian manufacturers were looking for an alternative to Starlink, but considered them a poor substitute and the solution was "on the shelf."
15/ "It seems that it was only the disabling of Starlink by Musk that spurred experiments with HiSKY, when the Ukrainian Armed Forces simply began to check what alternatives were available if it was not activated, and discovered that their use gave very good results.
16/ "It is possible that the terminals not only increase the efficiency of attacks in the "last mile" by quickly changing targets if the previous one on the list was hit, but also more effectively overcome air defence systems.
17/ "It is difficult to explain this series of successful attacks with mere luck... in 9 days, 7 oil refineries were hit, and on 2 November, the Linear Production and Dispatch Station "Samara" was also successfully hit.
18/ "I believe this was in place of some oil refinery, so there were actually 8 successful attacks in 9 days.
I think that the feedback allows UAVs to be switched to alternative routes in flight if a high percentage of interceptions is detected on the main planned route...
19/ "Nevertheless, even so, it is clear that now, in a single pass over an oil refinery, Ukraine is achieving what previously required multiple passes. There was a discussion about whether it was more profitable to hit primary or secondary processing.
20/ "When hitting the "primary" processing, the entire plant was shut down, but it seems that it is easier to repair, while secondary processing is much more difficult and expensive to repair, but shutting down a single unit did not shut down the plant,…
21/ …but only stopped the production of one type of fuel. Kyiv conducted experiments and, apparently, came to the conclusion that it is more profitable for them to attack only the "primary" processing.
22/ "Now, the Ukrainian Armed Forces can choose, they attack everything at once, and it should be expected that repairing oil refineries will become much more difficult and longer.
23/ "Perhaps we will see some owners being forced to abandon the repair of their enterprises, even under the threat of their "temporary" confiscation. Although it is unclear to whom the state will be able to transfer them in the current situation?
24/ "According to rumors, even [Rosneft CEO Igor] Sechin does not want to repair his own oil refineries, why would he repair someone else's?"
The Russians have reacted with hostility to the news that hiSky is being used by the Ukrainians.
25/ The pro-Kremlin media mogul Konstantin Malofeev has posted threats against the company, Israel, and Italy, where the terminals are assembled:
"Therefore, instead of Musk, Israel and Italy are now our legitimate targets. Are they sure they want this?"
26/ "Or will they themselves deal with HiSky Ltd. and Jabil Italy, who decided to expose their countries to a Russian retaliatory strike?" /end