BlueskyLinkedInRedditFacebookEmailCopy link

Carl T. Bergstrom

Published · Updated

I'm hate to do this, but all three of these experts have it wrong.

Gonzo is clearly a honeyeater, perhaps but not definitively most related to the tūī.

Allow me to make my case.

Let's start with beak morphology.

The honeyeaters have a diverse range of beak shapes, but almost always curved very much in the way that Gonzo's is. This is quite an unusual shape among birds and is pretty much found only among nectarivorous species.

Elinor Hay's has great images:

Noisy Friarbird (Philemon corniculatus) and Blue-faced Honeyeater (Entomyzon cyanotis), images from Elinor Hay. https://communities.springernature.com/posts/honeyeaters-prove-darwin-right
Scarlet Honeyeater (Myzomela sanguinolenta), Eastern Spinebill (Acanthorhynchus tenuirostris), and a New Holland Honeyeater (Phylidonyris novaehollandiae), images from Elinor Hay. https://communities.springernature.com/posts/honeyeaters-prove-darwin-right

Then plumage.

Honeyeaters and Gonzo alike are dandies. From that tufty crest thing he has to the impeccable wardrobe, Gonzo goes all out.

Now compare the tūī. (Photo, mine.)

Tui, a black bird with lace collar and ascot.
Gonzo, with bowtie

Song.

The tūī is famous for its melodious unearthly song, interrupted by the odds clicks and gurgles and cracks and buzzes.

That's literally gonzo's whole shtick in the theme song.

Muppet Show: Gonzo Openers, Seasons 1-5

Flight.

Tū are daredevils with some of the most amazing flight displays I've ever seen. Gonzo is....not such a great flyer, but it happened many of Aotearoa's best.

And whether leaping of a building in a cape, launching from a cannot, clinging to balloons, or floating through space, he tries.

Gonzo flying with cape.
Gonzo clinging to balloons

Personality.

Tūī and other honeyeaters strike me as sweet and lovely birds, prone to outbursts of exuberant chaos.

Photos mine.

New Holland Honeyeater.
Little wattlebird (a type of honeyeater)

And finally, there's a dead giveaway in the wonderful episode where Gonzo courts Camilla.

You all thought he was bringing her flowers.

No, he's brought dinner.

I rest my case.

Gonzo brings flowers to his love interest, Camilla the chicken.